Content Harry Potter Original Works Harry Potter/New Battlestar Galactica

Reviews

  • Previous
  • Next

Wolfric posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 6:08pm for The Reluctant Champion

I enjoyed the chapter. I particullarly liked the solution to the first task and the sonarus charm on the egg was inspired. Thanks for writing. W.

Vukk posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 6:06pm for The Reluctant Champion

I can't wait to see how you finish the story. So far, using odd methods, Harry has done better than he did in cannon and it is hilarious on what you think up.

Stanger posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 5:37pm for The Reluctant Champion

hey, nice with another new chapter, can't wait to keep reading this story

Ken Warner posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 3:51pm for The Reluctant Champion

very nice thanksgiving feast - thanks to you Jim
I am in admiration that you can twist your mind sideways enough to write this, and still be a functional member of society - amazing flexibility

warmest regards
ken

TheHard posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 2:47pm for The Reluctant Champion

Wow, after your other stories, I just can't see how you can be in a mindset to writte this! it's a masterpiece! :)

darthridian posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 1:38pm for The Reluctant Champion


excellent addition to this great story,

keep up the great writing.

blue artemis posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 1:22pm for The Reluctant Champion

I love this version of the Tri-Wizard tournament. Very cool.

noylj posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 12:43pm for The Reluctant Champion

Great to get an update. First bit of Thanksgiving cheer I've had.
Thanks.

dimriver posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 11:53am for The Reluctant Champion

Harry is a wise young man.

Bedrup posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 8:13am for The Reluctant Champion

I think H seemed a bit more sane in this chapter. Really liked it.

luckykas posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 7:32am for The Reluctant Champion

I already have Dead Eye. Bought it long back. It was very nice and I enjoyed it very much. The characterizations were very nice and you managed to make them very believable. The end seemed a bit ambiguous. The Father's fate was a bit predictable. I am deliberately being vague in this review so as to avoid giving away spoilers. Hoping Dead Eye has a sequel where Mike goes after his father.

Back to this fic, obviously it is very enjoyable. You keep to the canon but the events occur in such hilarious deviations. Voldemort is going to be pissed that he was thwarted by an egg and a toy. Really losing a lot of face there especially if the story becomes public. The Deaf Eaters would be the laughing stock of the wizarding world. Pettigrew though is realy starting to annoy, if he starts possessing people. Look forward to your updates...Happy Thanksgiving!

tula posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 7:00am for The Reluctant Champion

Since you almost made me die from laughter i've bought 2 more copies of Dead Eye from Amazon and will give those away as christmas gifts. How's that for gratefull reader ;)

Seriously, good job. I've enjoyed your past stories, but somehow the fun in this fic is better for me.

dougal74 posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 6:50am for The Reluctant Champion

Extremely funny as usual.

Bob Officer posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 6:48am for The Reluctant Champion

Wonderful, and still with the Greatest touch of humor I seen in a long time.

This story has to be the best prank on JKR ever.

DrT posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 5:58am for The Reluctant Champion

How rare Fudge ever has a clue -- fun fast little chapter!

Happy Thanksgiving!

amulder posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 4:35am for The Reluctant Champion

I like Padma. It's fun reading her inner monologue.

I also think that the Squid solution to the 2nd task was brilliantly original. And it flows stunningly well out of Harry's association with Luna.

The year did seem a bit rushed, but I understand your goal of keeping things to one year per chapter. Perhaps a bit more of Sirius would have worked?

thanks for sharing, I enjoy this bit of lunacy.

Evan Mayerle posted a comment on Thursday 26th November 2009 4:21am for The Reluctant Champion

Heh, a great present for Thanksgiving Day and, for me, one very nice birthday present. I love the way he's confounding all around him. The centaur's observation was right on the money and I doubt the wizarding world would understand.